Key Video Editing Mistakes You Should Avoid
Video restoration is both an art and a science, requiring a careful balance of technical skills, tools, and aesthetic judgment. In this article, we’ll explore some of the most common pitfalls in video restoration and how you can avoid them to achieve the best possible results.
While modern advancements—such as AI-powered tools and upscaling technologies—have made video restoration more accessible and efficient, there are still many challenges that restorers must navigate.
Whether you’re working on personal home videos or professional archival footage, certain common pitfalls can lead to less-than-ideal results.
1. Overprocessing the Footage
Pitfall:
One of the most frequent pitfalls in video restoration is overprocessing.
This occurs when noise reduction, sharpening, or other enhancement techniques are applied too aggressively, resulting in footage that looks overly smooth or artificial.
Excessive use of these tools can remove important details, make skin tones look plastic-like, and create an unnatural aesthetic.
How to Avoid It:
Moderation is key.
Use noise reduction tools sparingly and always compare the processed footage with the original to ensure that you’re not losing critical details. For better results, consider using AI-powered tools that allow for fine-tuning of parameters.
Many modern tools offer settings that enable you to gradually reduce noise or sharpen an image, allowing you to maintain a balance between enhancement and authenticity.
It’s also important to view the footage on different screens to see how it holds up in various environments.
What may look good on one monitor could appear over-smoothed or over-sharpened on another.
2. Ignoring the Importance of Color Grading
Pitfall:
When restoring old footage, especially from analog formats like VHS or film, color often fades or becomes distorted.
Another common video restoration pitfall I see is failing to properly color grade the footage, leading to washed-out visuals or unnatural colors that detract from the viewing experience.
How to Avoid It:
Color grading is an essential step in the restoration process.
Start by correcting any obvious color shifts or fading. Tools such as Adobe Premiere Pro, DaVinci Resolve, or AI-based color correction software can help restore the vibrancy and balance of colors. If you’re dealing with black-and-white footage, be cautious when applying colorization. Rely on historical references when possible to ensure color accuracy and avoid artificially bright or oversaturated hues.
It’s always useful to keep a reference image or clip from the same time period to guide your color grading decisions, ensuring that you stay true to the original aesthetic while making necessary improvements.
3. Neglecting Audio Restoration
Pitfall:
Video restoration often focuses heavily on the visual aspects, but neglecting the audio can be a major misstep.
Poor audio, such as hiss, pops, distortion, or uneven sound levels, can ruin the viewer’s experience even if the video looks pristine.
How to Avoid It:
Don’t overlook the audio restoration process.
Use tools like iZotope RX or Audacity to reduce noise, eliminate hums or pops, and restore audio clarity. Many AI-powered audio restoration tools can help with cleaning up audio tracks, ensuring they are just as well-preserved as the visuals.
Always check for issues like audio sync problems and make sure that any noise reduction you apply doesn’t remove important parts of the dialogue or sound effects.
Also, if you are working with older audio formats, it’s worth considering whether to convert mono soundtracks to stereo, depending on the intended use of the footage and the historical integrity of the audio.
4. Misusing Frame Interpolation
Pitfall:
Frame interpolation is a technique that AI tools use to generate new frames between existing ones, smoothing out motion and improving playback.
While this can make older, low-frame-rate footage look smoother, it can also lead to artifacts or unnatural movement if applied incorrectly.
So, this makes it to my list of frequent Video Restoration mistakes.
How to Avoid It:
Frame interpolation should be used with caution, particularly for films shot at lower frame rates, like 16 fps or 24 fps. Always test the results by playing back the footage to check for ghosting, motion blur, or strange warping of objects.
AI-based tools like Topaz Video Enhance AI can help with frame interpolation, but be sure to adjust the settings carefully and avoid excessive interpolation that may distort the original motion.
In some cases, it’s better to maintain the original frame rate for authenticity, especially if the film is meant to preserve historical accuracy.
Only apply frame interpolation if smoother motion is critical for the restoration project.
5. Failing to Preserve Aspect Ratio and Resolution
Pitfall:
Another common mistake is altering the aspect ratio or improperly scaling the video resolution during restoration.
This can result in distorted images or important details being cropped out. Many older formats, such as VHS or early digital video, use 4:3 aspect ratios, while modern screens are typically 16:9 or wider.
How to Avoid It:
Always be mindful of the original aspect ratio of the footage.
When upscaling or transferring video to a modern format, it’s important to preserve the aspect ratio to prevent stretching or squashing the image. Use pillarboxing (black bars on the sides) if necessary to maintain the correct proportions on modern screens.
Similarly, when upscaling footage to higher resolutions like 1080p or 4K, make sure you’re using the correct techniques to preserve image quality.
Avoid simply enlarging the footage without any enhancement—AI-based upscaling tools like Gigapixel AI or Topaz Video AI can help intelligently scale up the resolution without introducing significant artifacts.
6. Overlooking Proper Backup and Archiving
Pitfall:
Restoration is a time-consuming process, and nothing is worse than losing all your work due to technical failure, data corruption, or human error.
Failing to properly back up your files throughout the process can result in lost progress, particularly when dealing with large media files or long restoration projects.
How to Avoid It:
You do not want to be guilty of this next common restoration mistake!
Make regular backups of your project files, especially when working with large video files or complicated restoration workflows.
Use external drives or cloud-based storage solutions to create multiple versions of your project at different stages. This will allow you to revert back to earlier versions if something goes wrong or if you need to adjust the restoration technique.
Additionally, once the restoration is complete, be sure to archive both the original and restored files in high-quality formats for future access. It’s also a good idea to convert the footage into more sustainable, long-term formats like lossless ProRes or DNxHR for archiving.
I have seen many professionals lose projects, files and clients from this mistake.
7. Ignoring the Historical Context
Pitfall:
When restoring old footage, especially historical films or cultural artifacts, it’s easy to prioritize technical improvements over historical accuracy.
This can lead to altering the original intent of the footage, which may diminish its authenticity.
How to Avoid It:
Always consider the historical context of the footage you are restoring.
Before applying aggressive enhancements or colorizations, ask yourself whether these changes align with the intent of the original filmmakers.
For example, converting black-and-white films to color may be a stylistic choice for modern audiences, but could detract from the artistic or cultural value of the original piece.
Consult with historians, archivists, or film experts if you’re unsure about making certain modifications, especially when working with culturally significant media.
Conclusion
Video restoration is a rewarding process that can breathe new life into old footage, but it requires careful attention to detail and an understanding of common pitfalls.
By avoiding overprocessing, maintaining aspect ratio integrity, investing in proper color grading and audio restoration, and backing up your work consistently, you can avoid many of the common challenges faced by restorers.
Modern tools, particularly AI-driven technologies, can greatly simplify the restoration process, but they must be used wisely.
Balancing restoration improvements with historical authenticity will ensure that you preserve the original spirit of the footage while enhancing its quality for future generations.
What has been your biggest challenge in restoring old footage? Do you have any tips for avoiding common pitfalls? Let us know in the comments!
Read more: 👇
